25 January, 2012
- Can gold miners make a comeback in 2012?
- Recommended article: Something to look forward to: the collapse of the euro
- Yesterday’s close: FTSE 100 down 0.5% to 5,751... Gold down 0.69% to $1,665.68/oz... £/$ - 1.5626
It’s something that has wrong-footed and infuriated me in recent years. And it’s a theme that I, and many others like me, keep coming back to.
I’m talking about the relative underperformance of gold miners versus the metal.
That is, gold has risen, but the miners haven’t.
Why is this happening? And can we expect more of the same? Or will the tide finally turn in 2012?
ADVERTISEMENT
Revealed: The hidden world of ‘Ultra Dividends’
How you could receive five, ten, even twenty years’ worth of company “dividends”... in one super-charged payout!
Click here to find out everything.
Dr. Tubbs’ Research Investments is a regulated product issued by Fleet Street Publications Ltd. Your capital is at risk when you invest in shares, never risk more than you can afford to lose. Forecasts are not a reliable indicator of future results. Please seek independent financial advice if necessary. 0207 633 3600.
Gold miners had a terrible 2011
The gold price started 2011 at $1,424 an ounce. It ended the year at $1,564. A typical – in the context of the last ten years – 10% annual rise.
The miners, on the other hand, haven’t followed the script at all. The index of senior gold miners (the HUI), fell by 14% in 2011. The junior gold miners, as represented by the exchange-traded fund (ETF) GDXJ, fell 38%. And the gold explorers (GLDX) fell by nearly 50%.
Why has this happened? The theory is that if gold rises by 10%, gold miners should rise by even more: 15% to 20%, say. And the juniors and the lowly exploration companies should rise by still more, surely?
Yet with a few exceptions – well run companies, or those that have made big discoveries – it hasn’t been the case in recent years. Rather, gold stocks have only risen with gold if equity markets in general are rising too, or at least flat. If equities are tanking, as they did in 2011, gold stocks will too.
So why have the miners been so disappointing in recent years? Let’s look back at previous crises and see if it casts any light on today.
Gold miners thrived in the 1930s
Two previous long-term economic contractions during which gold flourished include the 1930s and the 1970s. And in the 1930s, gold stocks did incredibly well too. Homestake, the leading US gold miner of the time, rose by some 600%. The company’s big move came between 1932 and 1935 (from $2 to $6) but the Dow, too, was rising during this period. Homestake saw gentler gains between 1930 and 1932, a period when the Dow was falling.
But then, in 1933, it became illegal for Americans to own gold. Executive Order 6102, signed into existence on 5 April, 1933, by US President Franklin D Roosevelt forbade the “Hoarding of gold coin, gold bullion, and gold certificates within the continental United States” and required that citizens hand over their gold by 1 May.
So Homestake Mining and similar companies became one of the only ways Americans could buy gold, or at least an equivalent, and the stock benefited from this. On top of that, in 1934, the Gold Reserve Act saw gold revalued upwards from $20 to $35 an ounce. As a result, Homestake’s profits ballooned.
These days, many people now blame gold ETFs for the failure of gold stocks to deliver. A majority of gold mining executives questioned for the 2012 Pricewaterhouse Coopers (PwC) Gold Price Report, said that while the high gold price was having a positive impact on their share price, it wasn’t as significant as they’d have expected. Both the executives and gold analysts cited ETFs as the “main driver behind lagging share values”.
You can see what they’re getting at. ETFs such as GLD and PHAU have made it much easier to own gold. So they have attracted capital that might otherwise have gone into gold stocks. It means that gold investors don’t have to take individual company risk or cope with the many problems that come with owning a gold stock – incompetent management, escalating costs, labour issues, geo-political issues, funding, stock dilution, geological or metallurgical difficulties. These ETFs now occupy the niche that Homestake enjoyed in the 1930s.
However, I don’t entirely buy this complaint about ETFs. There are also ETFs that track the various gold mining sectors, so you don’t ever have to take on individual company risk if you don’t want to.
How did gold stocks do in the 1970s?
Below we see gold stocks in the 1970s, during gold’s last bull market. This is the US Gold Index.

(Thanks, as always, to Nick Laird of Sharelynx.com for preparing the chart)
You can see that from 1973 to 1974, (at a time when the S&P 500 was falling), gold stocks rose. At that point, it was still illegal for Americans to own gold (that ended on 1 January, 1975).
Gold stocks then went on to fall from mid-1975 to late 1978, before setting off on the mother of all bull market runs, which ended in 1980, along with gold’s bull market. The S&P 500 was broadly flat during this period.
I certainly don’t think the current bull market in gold is over just yet. In 1980 monetary policy suddenly became a lot tighter. We had interest rates over 15%. Paul Volcker was at the head of the Federal Reserve. We have no such fiscal discipline among central bankers today. And, interestingly, gold stocks – despite gold’s fall – broke to new highs twice in the 1980s. So the gold mining sector should still have plenty of good times ahead of it.
What will it take to turn the gold miners around?
But what could get gold miners out of their current slump? The PwC report notes that the companies are trying to make themselves more attractive. Some are getting more creative with dividends – linking them to the gold price, paying out more frequently and, in some cases, actually paying in gold bullion.
That’s good news. In a world simultaneously starved of cash, but awash with it, dividends are an attractive proposition. As I’ve long said, the strategy should be find the stuff, mine the stuff, make money, give it back to the shareholders. It’s not rocket science. Companies that do that beat the market.
Plans to make acquisitions are also rising – 29% of respondents were planning to spend their cash on acquisitions this year. Perhaps we’ll start to see the long-touted-but-never-realised frenzy of takeover and merger & acquisition activity in the junior sector. Here’s hoping.
Obviously, certain strategies will suit some companies, but not others. It’s up to management to make the right call. But company practice at all levels of the gold mining sector has to improve, otherwise they’ll remain mired in ‘dogsville’.
It is no longer enough to just be a gold company in a gold bull market – there are plenty of other ways for investors to get access to gold now. The market is demanding something more. And investors should be looking to those companies where management is acknowledging this and trying to do something about it.
Got a comment on this article? Leave a comment on the MoneyWeek website, here.
Until tomorrow,
Dominic Frisby
Our recommended article for today...
Something to look forward to: the collapse of the euro
- The received wisdom is that a break-up of the eurozone would be terrible for Britain. But it could be a bright spot in an otherwise bleak year, says Matthew Lynn: Something to look forward to: the collapse of the euro.
And for yesterday’s market update, see below...
ADVERTISEMENT

Claim the next 3 issues of MoneyWeek, Britain’s best-selling financial magazine, FREE
In the last 12 months, some MoneyWeek readers made a fortune from our money-making tips, advice and recommendations.
Now find out how MoneyWeek can protect and grow YOUR money in 2011… and beyond.
CLAIM YOUR 3 FREE ISSUES HERE
MoneyWeek magazine is an unregulated product published by MoneyWeek Ltd.
Market update
Click here for the latest stock market news and charts.
The FTSE 100 slipped back yesterday, closing down 0.5% at 5,751.
Banks took some of the biggest hits. RBS fell 3.9%, Lloyds slid 2.8% and Barclays lost 1.9%.
Miners were also among the biggest losers, with ENRC, Kazakhmys and Randgold Resources down between 3% and 2.1%.
But utilities performed well. International Power was the day’s highest climber, rising 2.4%, Centrica gained 1.8% and Scottish & Southern, National Grid and United Utilities added between 1.4% and 0.8%.
In Europe, the Paris CAC 40 fell 16 points to 3,322, and the German Xetra Dax was 17 points lower at 6,419.
In the US, the Dow Jones Industrial Average fell 0.3% to 12,675, the S&P 500 lost 0.1% to 1,314, but the Nasdaq Composite rose 0.1% to 2,786.
In Japan, the Nikkei 225 rose 1.1% to 8,883, and the broader Topix index added 1.3% to 767. China’s markets were closed for the New Year celebrations.
Brent spot was trading at $109.54 early today, and in New York, crude oil was at $98.77. Spot gold was trading at $1,667 an ounce, silver was at $32.09 and platinum was at $1,550.
In the forex markets this morning, sterling was trading against the US dollar at 1.5552 and against the euro at 1.1935. The dollar was trading at 0.7675 against the euro and 78.04 against the Japanese yen.
And in the UK, retailer WH Smith reported a 5% drop in like-for-like sales in the 21 weeks to 25 January. But it said improved profit margins and reduced costs meant it was still on course to meet its profit forecasts.
Top 20 spread betting accounts compared HERE
Don’t miss out on account opening offers like these:
£1000 offer | Free charts | Zero spreads | Free iPhone app
MONEY MORNING™ is the free daily email service brought to you by MoneyWeek. For a 3-week FREE trial of the MoneyWeek magazine & website, click here now:
Sign up for a 3-week FREE trial of MoneyWeek
Or if you prefer to place your order over the phone, just call 0207 633 3780 and one of our Customer Service representatives will take your order for you. Please quote reference number EMYK N117 to get your special discount and free issues.
Know someone who’d like to receive the Money Morning email themselves? Simply forward the following link to anyone you think could benefit from our daily service:
Sign up to the Free Money Morning email here
© 2012 MoneyWeek Ltd. All Rights Reserved. The content of this email may not be reproduced without the written consent of MoneyWeek Ltd. Registered Office: 8th Floor Friars Bridge Court, 41-45 Blackfriars Road, London SE1 8NZ. Registered in England No. 04016750. VAT No. GB 629 7287 94. MoneyWeek and Money Morning are registered trade marks owned by MoneyWeek Limited.
Shares are by their nature are speculative and can be volatile. Your capital is at risk so you should never invest more than you can safely afford to lose. Information in Money Morning is for general information only and is not intended to be relied upon by individual readers in making (or not making) specific investment decisions. Appropriate independent advice should be obtained before making any such decision.